A rare 1.5-acre estate on Peninsula Lake. Hills Island, blending history, privacy, and natural beauty. With over 540 feet of shoreline and both east and west exposures, it offers sun from dawn to dusk, showcasing stunning sunrises and sunsets. Direct access to 40 miles of boating across a scenic four-lake chain connects via the Muskoka River. Reachable in five minutes by boat from mainland parking and mooring. A three-slip boathouse along the sheltered east shoreline provides storage and launching for lake adventures. The property offers seclusion without sacrificing convenience. The charming 1904 cottage, a historic relic, once served as a stop for the steamship from Huntsville to North Portage and was part of the small resort, The Isle of Dunelg, favoured by upscale summer visitors. Remaining in the same family for 50 years, it's a treasured legacy. While full restoration is needed, this presents a rewarding project for heritage lovers. Wake to sunrises with coffee on the dock. The inviting main cottage features an eat-in kitchen, dining area, anchored by an original stone fireplace. In the evenings, relax by the granite fireplace in the spacious living room. A wraparound veranda offers sunset views, with a path through ancient white pines to the west shoreline for evening swims. Accommodating family and guests, it includes two main bedrooms and four private cabins, sleeping 15 comfortably; ideal for multi-generational gatherings. A sunny meadow, once a tennis court, provides space for play or future plans, framed by nature. Dunelg is a timeless retreat where history lives in every stone and tree, awaiting its next chapter.
Address
4 Hills Island
List Price
$769,000
MLS® Status
New
Expiration Date
2026-04-30
Property Type
Residential Freehold
Type of Dwelling
Detached
Style of Home
Bungalow
Transaction Type
For Sale
Area
Lake of Bays
Sub-Area
Franklin
Region
Muskoka
Bedrooms
6
Bedrooms (Total)
6
Rooms Above Grade
8
Bathrooms
2
Floor Area
1100 - 1500 Sq. Ft.
Lot Size Source
MPAC
Lot Depth
253
Lot Size Range (Acres)
.50 - 1.99
Lot Size Units
Feet
Lot Width
540
Parcel Number
480660390
Occupant Type
Owner
Cross Street
Maplehurst & Shaw
Approx. Age
100+ Years
MLS® Number
X12345010
Listing Brokerage
Chestnut Park Real Estate
Basement Area
None
Postal Code
P0B 1A0
Posession Details
Flexible
Parking
None
Tax Amount
$4,440.00
Tax Year
2025
Interior Features
Other
Central Vacuum
No
Family Room
No
Ensuite Laundry
No
Special Designation
Unknown
Standard Status
Active
Disclosures
Unknown
Board Or Association
One Point Association of REALTORS
Heat Source
Wood
Heat Type
Other
Cooling Features
None
Construction Materials
Wood
Direction Faces
West
Fireplace
Yes
Foundation Details
Piers
Garage
No
Garage Type
None
Kitchens Total
1
Kitchens Above Grade
1
Pool Features
None
Roof
Asphalt Shingle
Tax Legal Description
PT DUNELG ISLAND (FORMERLY HILLS ISLAND) IN PENINSULA LAKE FRANKLIN AS IN DM79121; LAKE OF BAYS
Water View
Direct
Waterfront
Yes
Docking Type
Private
Waterfront
Direct
Waterfront Accessory
Wet Boathouse-Double
Waterfront Features
Boathouse, Stairs to Waterfront, Island
Water Body Name
Peninsula Lake
Water Body Type
Lake
Shoreline
Natural
Shoreline Allowance
None
Access To Property
Water Only, Private Docking
Alternative Power
None
Sewer
Septic